93+
ANTONIO GALLONI "The 2013 Cabernet Sauvignon Martha's Vineyard is a powerful wine. Beguiling aromatics make a strong opening statement. Pine, rosemary, mint, sweet red cherry, pomegranate and a touch of new oak give the wine its bright, lifted feel. Even with considerable air, and also taking into account the personality of the year, the 2013 Martha's remains closed down and not at all expressive. My impression is that this could have been a materially better wine."
92
FALSTAFF: "Dunkles Rubingranat, opaker Kern, violette Reflexe, zarter Wasserrand. Intensive Minzenote, ein Hauch von Eukalyptusöl, Schwarze Ribiseln, rauchig-tabakige Nuancen sind unterlegt, sehr lautes, individuelles Bukett. Saftig, süße Textur, ein Hauch von Dörrobst, reife Tannine, helles Nougat, etwas Feigen im Nachhall, bereits entwickelt und gut antrinkbar."
95
JAMES SUCKLING: "The blackcurrants and blackberries with lavender and rosemary really pop out of the glass. Full body, tight and polished tannins and a long, flavorful finish. Shows tension and focus with a precise finish. Very finely textured. A classical wine. From organically grown grapes. Try in 2021 and onwards."
96
WINE ENTHUSIAS: "From Tom and Martha May’s famous, organically farmed site in the heart of the appellation, this is a blockbuster vintage of the 100% varietal wine, immaculately structured and full of fresh acidity. The menthol is there, subtle, heightened by delicate, silky layerings of orange peel, red currant and cinnamon."